An analysis of inspection in probation and its impact on practitioners, practice and providers

This article analyses the impact of Her Majesty's Inspectorate Probation on practice, providers and practitioners. Since 1936 HMI has aimed to improve practice through independently inspecting probation services. However, no research looked at its those it inspects. is important not only because evidence whether inspection improves delivery in other sectors weak but also oversight potential create accountability overload. Following a brief overview history, aims policy context for presents data from interviews with 77 participants across field probation. Overall, were positive about Inspectorate. suggest that places considerable operational burden staff organisations real emotional consequences Staff experience case as reflection validation there less direct practice. Ultimately, argues can monitor whilst contributing improving providing way reflect their work, yet this balance difficult strike. Finally, considers implications these findings service.